Protein Power Diet
Review
Originally published in 1996, this diet book follows in the
tradition of the Atkins Diet and Zone Diet, being high in fat,
high in protein and low in carbs, except it's information on
insulin and glucagon is more accurate and detailed.
Written by the Eades, a husband and wife doctor team. Protein
Power says that you need to control insulin response within your
body to achieve health and normal weight. Depending on your
activity level, they allocate amounts of protein required at each
meal. You are allowed a modest amount of carbs (30-50g per day)
but you must carefully monitor this amount. You need to count
everything and eat specific amounts at certain times.
Protein Power also recommends diet supplements.
Although well-presented and written by two doctors, Protein Power
has three specific weaknesses.
First, estimating protein needs on the basis of activity level is
not supported by known medical evidence.
Second, as with all low-carb diets, Protein Power causes ketosis
which is not generally recommended. According to Susan B. Roberts,
PhD, a professor of nutrition and psychiatry at Tufts University
in Boston, Mass., low carb diets are not healthy:
"Because they cut back on foods that have multiple health
benefits, they may reduce health in the long term."
Third, the idea that a high protein, low-carb diet helps you lose
weight by reducing insulin levels is inaccurate. Reducing your
intake of any food will achieve this.
Protein Power - Claims
Quick weight loss.
Scientifically researched (by the Eades).
Keeps disease at bay.
Reduces your insulin.
Protein Power - Drawbacks
Protein estimation by physical exercise is controversial!
Ketosis, caused by lack of carbs, is unhealthy.
Not a long term solution to weight loss.
Protein Power - Summary
Not recommended, due to long term health risks of low carb
content.
Diet Review
No diet review can be more than a reasoned opinion on a particular
diet plan or weight loss method. We don't have a monopoly of diet
wisdom, so we welcome all
comments on
our Diet Reviews.
|
